FS: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Youth Issues

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Youth Issues

(Taken from the SIECUS Report, Volume 29, Number 4 - April/May 2001)

During adolescence, young people form their sexual identity. This SIECUS Fact Sheet reviews research on sexual orientation during adolescence and presents the available statistics on lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) students. Many of the studies are regional or local. Much of the research focuses on samples of LGBT youth that are disproportionately at risk.

Sexual Self-Concept, Orientation, and Identity

Sexual self-concept is an individual’s evaluation of his or her sexual feelings and actions¹
Developing a sexual self-concept is a key developmental task of adolescence²
During adolescence, young people tend to experience their first adult erotic feelings, experiment with sexual behaviors, and develop a strong sense of their own gender identity and sexual orientation³
Gender identification includes understanding that a person is male or female as well as understanding the roles, values, duties, and responsibilities of being a man or a woman⁴

Sexual Orientation during Adolescence

These statistics are from a report written by the Safe Schools Coalition of Washington that describes several other studies:⁵

In Seattle, of 8,406 respondents in the ninth to twelfth grades, 4.5 percent of respondents described themselves as gay, lesbian, and bisexual (GLB). Ninety-one percent described themselves as heterosexual. Another four percent indicated that they were “not sure” of their orientations.
In Massachusetts, of 3,982 respondents in the ninth to twelfth grades, two percent of the students described themselves as GLB and 3three percent reported that they had same-gender sexual experience
In Vermont, of 8,636 respondents in the ninth to twelfth grades, 5.3 percent of young men and 3.4 percent of young women reported having engaged in same-gender “sexual activity”
In Minnesota, of 36,254 respondents in the seventh to twelfth grades, 1.1 percent of students described themselves as “bisexual,” “mostly homosexual,” or “100 percent homosexual.” Same-gender sexual attraction and anticipated future same-gender sexual experience was reported by 5.1 percent, and same-gender sexual fantasy was reported by 2.8 percent of respondents.
Uncertainty about sexual orientation declined with age, from 25.9 percent of 12-year-old students to five percent of 17-year-old students⁶
In San Francisco, of 1,914 respondents in the ninth to twelfth grades, 0.2 percent of respondents reported same-gender sexual intercourse
Of 13,454 American Indian youth in the seventh to twelfth grades at reservation schools throughout the nation, 1.6 percent of students described themselves as “bisexual,” “mostly homosexual,” or “100 percent homosexual.” Same-gender sexual experience was reported by 1.3 percent of respondents. Same-gender attraction and anticipated future same-gender sexual experience was reported by 4.4 percent and same-gender sexual fantasy by 4.4 percent of respondents.

A national survey of 1,752 college students found: ⁷

Forty-eight percent of self-identified gay and bisexual college students became aware of their sexual preference in high school while 26 percent found their true sexuality in college
Twenty percent of self-identified gay and bisexual men knew that they were gay or bisexual in junior high school, and 17 percent said they knew in grade school
Six percent of self-identified gay or bisexual women knew that they were gay or bisexual in junior high school, and 11 percent knew in grade school

Sexual Behaviors

A study of 394 self-identified bisexual and homosexual adolescents in the seventh to twelfth grades who participated in the 1986-87 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found: ⁸

35.8 percent of younger girls (“younger” was defined as 14 years of age or younger) and 14.3 percent of younger boys reported having had any kind of sexual experience with a male
45.2 percent of younger boys compared to 8.2 percent of younger girls reported sexual experience with a female
The majority of younger girls reported fantasizing about males, and the majority of younger boys reported fantasizing about females. However, 27.1 percent of younger girls compared to 18.6 percent of younger boys reported fantasizing about both genders.
74.1 percent of older boys (“older” was defined as 15 years of age or older) and 26.9 percent of older girls reported sexual experience with a female
For older adolescents, half of the boys and girls reported fantasizing exclusively about the opposite gender, while 41.6 percent of older girls and 36.4 percent of older boys reported fantasizing about both genders

A study of 3,816 public school students 12 to19 years of age who participated in the 1987 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found: ⁹

Bisexual/lesbian respondents (33 percent) were as likely as their heterosexual peers (29 percent) to have ever had penile-vaginal intercourse, while those unsure of their sexual orientation (22 percent) were less likely to have engaged in penile-vaginal intercourse
Of the respondents who had ever had penile-vaginal intercourse, 62 percent of bisexual/lesbian young women said they had first done so before the of age 14, as compared to 45 percent of heterosexual respondents and 46 percent of those unsure of their sexual orientation. However, this difference was no longer statistically significant when controlled for self-reported history of sexual abuse.
Among sexually experienced respondents, bisexual/lesbian women were significantly more likely to engage daily or several times a week in penile-vaginal intercourse (22 percent) than their heterosexual peers (15 percent) or those unsure of their sexual orientation (17 percent)

A study of ninth to twelfth grade public high school students in the 1995 Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance found:¹⁰

Gay, lesbian, and bisexual orientation was associated with having had sexual intercourse before 13 years of age
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual orientation was associated with having sexual intercourse with four or more partners both in a lifetime and in the past three months
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual orientation was associated with having experienced sexual contact against one's will.

Contraceptive Use

A study of 3,816 public school students 12 to19 years of age who participated in the 1987 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found:¹¹

Among sexually experienced respondents, 44 percent of those unsure of their sexual orientation reported no use of contraception as compared to 30 percent of bisexual/lesbian respondents and 23 percent of heterosexual respondents
Of the respondents who used any contraceptive method, 12 percent of bisexual/lesbian respondents, 15 percent of heterosexual respondents, and nine percent of those unsure of their sexual orientation used ineffective methods (such as withdrawal or rhythm)

HIV Risk

A study of 2,621 gay and bisexual men 15 to 25 years of age in 10 U.S. cities found that more than one-fifth (22 percent) of young gay or bisexual men had never tested for HIV and over half had not tested in the six months prior to the study. This study also found that these men were more likely to test if they knew of a place where they felt “comfortable” and if they had exposure to information from a variety of prevention sources such as flyers or workshops.¹²
A study of 3,492 gay and bisexual men, 15 to 22 years of age in seven U.S. cities found that one in six young men who had sexual intercourse with men had recently had sexual intercourse with women. In addition, nearly one-fourth of those men reported recently having had unprotected sexual intercourse with both men and women. The study confirms that young bisexual men are a “bridge” for HIV transmission to women, particularly since 6.6 percent of the bisexual men in the study were HIV positive.¹³

Pregnancy

A study of 3,816 public school students 12 to19 years of age who participated in the 1987 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found:¹⁴

Bisexual/lesbian respondents reported approximately twice as great a prevalence of pregnancy (12 percent) as either unsure or heterosexual young women (five to six percent)
Among respondents who had been pregnant, 24 percent of bisexual/lesbian respondents reported multiple pregnancies as opposed to 10 percent of heterosexual respondents and 15 percent of those unsure about their sexual orientation

Safety, Harassment, Violence, and Other Social Issues

A national survey of 496 lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and questioning (LGBTQ) students under 19 years of age who were affiliated with local youth service organizations found:¹⁵

Two out of five youth (41.7 percent) did not feel safe in their school because they are LGBTQ (n=191)
86.7 percent of LGBTQ youth who felt safe in their schools still reported sometimes or frequently hearing homophobic remarks
Despite reporting feeling safe, 46 percent of LGBTQ youth reported verbal harassment, 36.4 percent reported sexual harassment, 12.1 percent reported physical harassment, and 6.1 percent reported physical assault in their school
91.4 percent of LGBTQ youth reported that they sometimes or frequently hear homophobic remarks in their school (words such as “faggot,” “dyke,” or “queer”)
99.4 percent of LGBTQ youth reported hearing homophobic remarks from other students (n=481)
Over one-third (36.6 percent) of LGBTQ youth reported hearing homophobic remarks from faculty or school staff (n=177)
Over one-third (39.2 percent, n=184) of LGBTQ youth reported that no one ever intervened when homophobic remarks were heard. Almost half (46.5 percent, n=218) reported that someone intervened only some of the time. Other students were more often reported to intervene (82.4 percent) than were faculty (66.5 percent)
38.2 percent of youth did not feel comfortable speaking to school staff about LGBTQ issues (n=179)
47.7 percent of youth from the Midwest, 41.7 percent of youth from the Northeast, 31.6 percent of youth from the South, and 29.4 percent of youth from the West reported being uncomfortable talking to any school staff member about LGBTQ issues
69 percent of LGBTQ youth reported experiencing some form of harassment or violence (n=342)
61.1 percent (n=300) of LGBTQ youth reported experiences of verbal harassment with 45.9 percent (n=106) having experienced it daily 46.5 percent (n=224) reported experiences of sexual harassment, 27.6 percent (n=134) reported experiences of physical harassment, and 13.7 percent (n=68) reported experiences of physical assault
73.7 percent of transgender youth reported hearing homophobic remarks “sometimes” or “frequently”
94 percent of white youth, 85.7 percent of African-American/Black youth, 80.6 percent of Latino(a) youth, and 93.8 percent of Asian/Pacific Islander youth reported hearing homophobic remarks “sometimes” or “frequently”
98.3 percent of youth from the Midwest, 92.3 percent of youth from the South, 89.4 percent of youth from the West, and 86.4 percent of youth from the Northeast reported hearing homophobic remarks “sometimes” or “frequently”
40 percent of Latino(a) youth, 29.6 percent of White youth, 18.8 percent of Asian/Pacific Islander youth, and 13.4 percent of African-American/Black youth reported being physically harassed at their schools because of their sexual orientation or gender identity
40.4 percent of youth from the Midwest, 30.2 percent of youth from the West, 21.8 percent of youth from the Northeast, and 17.1 percent of youth from the South reported being physically harassed at their schools because of their sexual orientation and gender identity

A study of ninth to twelfth grade public high school students in the 1995 Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance found:¹⁶

Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were more than four times as likely to report being threatened with a weapon on school property
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were almost five times as likely to report failing to attend school because of their fear about safety
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were more likely to carry a weapon in the 30 days prior to the survey
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were more likely to have engaged in a physical fight in the12 months prior to the survey

A study of 3,816 public school students 12 to19 years of age who participated in the 1987 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found: ¹⁷

Bisexual/lesbian respondents were more likely to report physical abuse (19 percent) than heterosexual adolescents (12 percent) and those unsure of their sexual orientation (11 percent)
Twenty-two percent of bisexual/lesbian respondents reported a past history of sexual abuse versus 15 percent of heterosexual respondents and 13 percent of those unsure of their sexual orientation

A study in the New York juvenile justice system estimates that anywhere from four to 10 percent of the juvenile delinquent population identify as LGBT.¹⁸

Sexual Abuse

A study of 394 self-identified bisexual and homosexual adolescents in the seventh to twelfth grade who participated in the 1986-87 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey found:¹⁹

The proportion of younger respondents (defined as 14 years of age or younger) with a history of sexual abuse was almost four times greater among girls (14.9 percent) than boys (4.1 percent)
None of the younger boys and 42.1 percent of the younger girls who reported a history of sexual abuse discussed the abuse with someone
30.7 percent of older girls (defined as 15 years of age or older) compared to 16.7 percent of older boys reported a history of sexual abuse
54.5 percent of older boys and 45.8 percent of older girls who reported a history of sexual abuse had never discussed the abuse with anyone

Suicide

A study of ninth- to twelfth-grade public high school students in the 1995 Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance found:²⁰

Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were more than three times as likely to have attempted suicide in the past 12 months

A Massachusetts Department of Public Health study found:²¹

Of 4,000 Massachusetts high school students, approximately 40 percent of gay and bisexual students attempted suicide compared to approximately 10 percent of their heterosexual peers.

Substance Abuse

A study of public high school students in the ninth to twelfth grades in the 1995 Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance found:²²

Gay, lesbian, and bisexual orientation was associated with an increased lifetime frequency of use of cocaine, crack, anabolic steroids, inhalants, “illegal,” and injectable drugs
Gay, lesbian, and bisexual youth were more likely to report using tobacco, marijuana, and cocaine before 13 years of age

Perceptions of School Personnel

In a random sample of high school health teachers, one in five surveyed said that students in their classes often used abusive language when describing homosexuals²³
A national study of secondary school counselors’ perceptions of adolescent homosexuals found that 25 percent perceived that teachers exhibited significant prejudice toward homosexual students and that 41 percent believed that schools were not doing enough to help gay and lesbian students adjust to their school environments²⁴
In a random sample of high school health teachers, one third perceived the schools were not doing enough to help homosexual adolescents²⁵
In a study of gay and lesbian adolescents 14 to 21 years of age, 23 percent of females and 25 percent of males reported that they were able to talk with their school counselors about their sexual orientation²⁶

Support for LGBT Youth

A 1988 national survey of heterosexual male youths 15 to 19 years of age found that only 12 percent felt that they could have a gay person as a friend.²⁷ In a 14-city survey, nearly three-fourths of lesbian and gay youth first disclosed their sexual identity to friends. Forty-six percent lost a friend after coming out to her or him.²⁸ In a study of gay and lesbian adolescents 14 to 21 years of age, less than one in five of the surveyed gay and lesbian adolescent students could identify someone who was very supportive of them.²⁹

Student Attitudes about LGBT Issues

A national survey of 2,804 American high school students 16 to 18 years of age with an “A” or “B” grade average found:³⁰

Nearly 40 percent say that they are prejudiced against homosexuals
Nearly four out of five (78 percent) feel homosexuals should be permitted to enlist in the military
Three out of four (74 percent) feel gays should be allowed to teach school
More than three out of five high-achieving teens (62 percent) believe it is okay to have a gay Girl or Boy Scout Leader
Two out of three (68 percent) believe gays should be able to coach youth sports
More than half believe gays should be allowed to marry (54 percent) and to join the clergy (54 percent)

Parental Support for LGBT Issues

A national survey of 1,000 American parents found:³¹

Seventy-six percent of parents nationwide would be comfortable talking to their child about issues related to homosexuality or gay and lesbian people
Sixty-seven percent of parents nationwide favor teaching children that gay people are just like other people
Sixty-two percent of parents nationwide would be comfortable talking to their child’s teacher about issues related to homosexuality or gay and lesbian people
Sixty-one percent of parents nationwide said that homosexuality is “something I would discuss with my children if they asked me questions, but not something I would raise with them on my own”
Fifty-six percent of parents nationwide favor allowing groups or clubs on school campuses to promote tolerance and prevent discrimination against gay and lesbian students
Fifty-five percent of parents nationwide would be comfortable if their child’s teacher were gay or lesbian
Fifty-five percent of parents nationwide favor allowing openly gay teachers to teach in middle schools and high schools
Fifty-four percent of parents nationwide would be comfortable if their child’s friend were gay or lesbian
When asked, “What is the youngest age you feel you might need to talk to your children about homosexuality?”
- Under five years of age—two percent
- Five to six years of age—eight percent
- Seven to eight years of age—eight percent
- Eight to nine years of age—11 percent
- Nine to 10 years of age—21 percent
- 11 to 12 years of age—20 percent
- 13 to 14 years of age—14 percent
- 15 to 16 years of age—four percent
- 17 to 18 years of age—one percent
- Over 18 years of age—two percent
- Do not know—10 percent

Teaching About Sexual Orientation in the Schools

Forty-six percent of a random sample of high school health teachers formally taught about homosexuality. Among those teachers, 48 percent spent less than one class period teaching about homosexuality.³²
Thirty-seven percent of high school health teachers reported that they would feel very comfortable teaching about homosexuality while 20 percent believed that they also would be very competent³³
Sixty-six percent of high school health teachers identified mass media as the most commonly used source of information regarding homosexuality³⁴
In a self-reported study, sixty-two percent of health and education professionals stated that they needed to update their knowledge or skills to discuss or teach homosexuality and bisexuality³⁵
In one study of gay and lesbian adolescents 14 to 21 years of age, half of the students said that homosexuality had been discussed in their classes. Of those, 50 percent of females and 37 percent of males said it was handled negatively.³⁶

References

Facing Facts: Sexual Health for America’s Adolescents (New York: SIECUS, 1995), p. 12.
Ibid., pp. 10, 12.
Ibid., p. 10.
Ibid., p. 12.
B. Reis and E. Saewyc, Eighty-Three Thousand Youth: Selected Findings of Eight Population-based Studies As They Pertain to Anti-gay Harassment and the Safety and Well-being of Sexual Minority Students (Seattle, WA: Safe Schools Coalition of Washington, 1999).
G. Remafedi, M. Resnick, R. Blum, and L. Harris, "Demography of Sexual Orientation in Adolescents," Pediatrics, vol. 89, no. 4 (April 1992), pp. 714-21.
L. Elliott and C. Brantley, Sex on Campus: The Naked Truth About the Real Sex Lives of College Students (New York: Random House, 1997), pp. 163-4.
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, P. A. Heinz, R. W. Blum, and M. Resnick, “Gender Differences in Health and Risk Behaviors among Bisexual and Homosexual Adolescents,” Journal of Adolescent Health, vol. 23, no. 2, (August 1998), pp. 181-8.
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, R. W. Blum, and M. D. Resnick, “Sexual Intercourse, Abuse and Pregnancy among Adolescent Women: Does Sexual Orientation Make a Difference?,” Family Planning Perspectives, vol. 31, no. 3, (May/June 1999), pp. 127-31.
R. Garofalo, R. Cameron Wolf, S. Kessel, J. Palfrey, and R. H. DuRant, “The Association between Health Risk Behaviors and Sexual Orientation among a School-based Sample of Adolescents,” Pediatrics, vol. 101, no. 5, (May 1998), pp. 895-902.
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, R. W. Blum, and M. D. Resnick, “Sexual Intercourse, Abuse and Pregnancy among Adolescent Women.”
HIV Trends in U.S. Highlight Need for Expanded Prevention, (U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Press Briefing at the Thirteenth International AIDS Conference, Durban, South Africa, July 10, 2000).
Ibid.
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, R. Blum, and M. D. Resnick, “Sexual Intercourse, Abuse and Pregnancy among Adolescent Women.”
1999 National School Climate Survey (New York: GLSEN, 1999).
R. Garofalo, R. Cameron Wolf, S. Kessel, et al., “The Association between Health Risk Behaviors and Sexual Orientation among a School-based Sample of Adolescents.”
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, R. W. Blum, et al., “Sexual Intercourse, Abuse and Pregnancy among Adolescent Women.”
R. Feinstein, A. Greenblatt, L. Hass, S. Kohn, and, J. Rana, Justice for All? A Report on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgendered Youth in the New York Juvenile Justice System (New York: Lesbian and Gay Project of the Urban Justice Center, 2001). p. 6.
E. M. Saewyc, L. H. Bearinger, P. A. Heinz, et al., “Gender Differences in Health and Risk Behaviors among Bisexual and Homosexual Adolescents.”
R. Garofalo, R. Cameron Wolf, S. Kessel, et al., “The Association between Health Risk Behaviors and Sexual Orientation among a School-based Sample of Adolescents.”
P. Healy, “Suicides in State Top Homicides,” Boston Globe, (Feb. 28, 2001)
R. Garofalo, R. Cameron Wolf, S. Kessel, et al., “The Association between Health Risk Behaviors and Sexual Orientation among a School-based Sample of Adolescents.”
S. K. Telljohann, J. H. Price, M. Poureslami, A. Easton, "Teaching about Sexual Orientation by Secondary Health Teachers," Journal of School Health, vol. 65, no. 1 (Jan. 1995), pp. 18-22.
S. K. Telljohann, et al. (Jan.1995), p. 18; J. H. Price and S. K. Telljohann, "School Counselor’s Perceptions of Adolescent Homosexuals," Journal of School Health, vol. 61, no. 10 (Dec. 1991), pp. 433-8.
S. K. Telljohann, et al, (Jan. 1995), p. 18.
S. K. Telljohann and J. H. Price, "A Qualitative Examination of Adolescent Homosexuals’ Life Experiences: Ramifications for Secondary School Personnel," Journal of Homosexuality, vol. 26, no.1 (1993), pp. 41-56.
W. Marsiglio, "Attitudes toward Homosexual Activity and Gays as Friends: A National Survey of Heterosexual 15- to 19-Year-Old Males," Journal of Sex Research, vol. 30, no. 1 (Feb. 1993), pp. 12-17.
C. Ryan and D. Futterman, "Lesbian and Gay Youth: Care and Counseling," Adolescent Medicine, State of the Art Reviews, vol. 8, no. 2 (June,1997), p. 221.
S. K. Telljohann and J. H. Price (1993), pp. 41-56.
Y2K Who’s Who Among American High School Students (Lake Forest, IL: Educational Communications, Inc., 2000)
Horizons Foundation National Survey of 1000 Parents (San Francisco, CA: Horizons Foundation, 2001)
S. K. Telljohann, et al. (Jan. 1995), p. 20.
Ibid.
Ibid.
D. L. Kerr, D. D. Allensworth, J. A. Gayle, "The ASHA National HIV Education Needs Assessment of Health and Education Professionals," Journal of School Health, vol. 59, no. 7 (Sept. 1989), p. 301-7.
S. K. Telljohann and J. H. Price (1993), pp. 41-56.